News

Carl and Laura Lentz Privately Apologize to ‘Heart of Dating’ Host for Hurt She Carried From Hillsong NYC


Published: Nov 18, 2026 11:41 PM EST

Thirteen years after Kait Warman cried in Carl and Laura Lentz's living room, the couple sat down with her in hers. Warman, host of the Christian relationship podcast Heart of Dating, said the former Hillsong NYC pastor and his wife arrived early for an interview this fall to apologize in private for hurt she had carried since her time at the church. 

Warman said she was in an abusive relationship when she attended Hillsong NYC. The church was a source of support during one of the lowest periods of her life, she recalled, and it was also a place where she was hurt. When she left, she believed that even some of the people she had looked up to doubted her judgment.

According to Warman, Carl and Laura arrived 15 minutes before the podcast taping so they could sit with her. She said they apologized and cried during the conversation, all before the cameras were rolling. She described the apology as sincere and said she had already forgiven them years before she knew whether they would ever speak again. 

"Forgiveness always needs to happen, but reconciliation isn't guaranteed," Warman wrote. She said people can forgive and move forward even if an apology never comes. She also addressed readers who had been hurt at Hillsong, affirming their experiences and speaking only for what she witnessed in her own living room. 

In the Heart of Dating episode, Carl and Laura discuss how they met, the breakdown of their marriage and what they learned about rebuilding trust and setting boundaries. Listen to the full interview.

Support - In the U.S., the National Domestic Violence Hotline offers free, confidential support 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233 or by texting START to 88788. TheHotline.org. National Domestic Violence Hotline