Franklin Graham thanked former President George W. Bush and former First Lady Laura Bush after the couple joined an overwhelming majority of voters at their longtime Dallas church in supporting a break with the United Methodist Church. The October vote drew 4,775 church members, with more than 90% backing the departure, according to ChurchLeaders.
The Bushes have attended Highland Park since the late 1980s. A spokesperson for the former president told The New York Times that the couple was grateful to the Rev. Matt Tuggle for guiding the congregation through the dispute.
Sharing the Times report, Graham wrote, "Thank you Highland Park Methodist Church and President Bush for doing the right thing and standing with the Word of God."
Graham linked the vote to changes the United Methodist Church adopted in 2024, when the denomination lifted its bans on the ordination of gay and lesbian clergy and the performance of same-sex weddings. Highland Park's leaders have described the dispute in terms of church governance and their congregation's longstanding authority over local decisions.
The disagreement over governance predates the denomination's 2024 vote. In 2022, Highland Park removed references to the United Methodist Church from its governing documents and adopted the corporate name Highland Park Methodist Church while continuing to operate publicly as Highland Park United Methodist Church. In August 2026, a regional UMC conference sued the church, arguing that its governing documents conflicted with denominational rules.
The regional conference rejected the October vote as invalid, and a United Methodist bishop subsequently removed Tuggle as senior pastor of the congregation recognized by the denomination. Tuggle continues to lead Highland Park Methodist Church, which worships in the original sanctuary and draws a reported 8,000 people each week. The congregation recognized by the denomination continues as Highland Park United Methodist Church and meets at a different location, with about 100 people attending weekly, according to ChurchLeaders.
The two congregations now worship under nearly identical names. Tuggle has expressed interest in forming a network with other congregations he describes as moderate, while Highland Park United Methodist Church continues its ministry within the denomination.















