Tommaso Cioni's name is trending again this weekend, seven-plus months into the search for his mother-in-law, Nancy Guthrie - but the renewed attention traces back to unverified online chatter, not any new development from investigators.
Cioni, married to Nancy's daughter Annie, was the last known person to see Nancy before she vanished from her Tucson, Arizona home on the night of January 31, after dropping her off around 9:50 p.m. That timeline made him an early target of internet speculation. But Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos has publicly and repeatedly cleared him - along with every member of the Guthrie family - as a suspect, calling the family "cooperative and gracious" and stating plainly they are "victims in this case." Cioni has also passed a polygraph, according to a former SWAT commander who reviewed the case publicly.
This week's resurgence centers on unverified claims circulating on social media about an old band Cioni reportedly played in years ago, pointed to by an anonymous online account with no connection to the investigation. No law enforcement source, official statement, or credible outlet has linked that claim to Nancy's disappearance in any way - and Sheriff Nanos has previously and directly criticized this kind of speculation as "wrong" and "cruel" to a grieving family.
Nancy, 84, remains missing. No suspect has been publicly named, and a combined reward of more than $1.2 million remains active for information leading to her recovery.
Through it all, the Guthrie family has continued to lean on prayer and their faith community - and continued to ask that online speculation not add to their pain.
Related Article: Viral "Pink Tablet" Claim Spreads Online - But Police Say No Such Device Was Ever Reported Stolen
