The search for Nancy Guthrie is entering a critical phase as new reports raise questions about the evolving role of federal authorities in the investigation.
Nancy Guthrie, 84, was reported missing on February 1 from her home near Tucson, Arizona. The Pima County Sheriff's Department continues to lead the case, with assistance from the FBI. Nearly three weeks later, no arrests have been made and no suspects have been publicly identified.
Recent reporting from Fox News suggests the FBI has expressed interest in taking a larger role in the case as progress has slowed. According to the outlet, federal officials believe additional resources or oversight could help advance the investigation.
"It would be the best thing that could happen for this case," a source told Fox News, referring to increased federal involvement. "Unfortunately, the pushback is from the sheriff himself."
Sheriff Chris Nanos has not publicly confirmed any dispute between agencies. In a recent NBC News interview, he addressed forensic developments, stating that DNA evidence connected to the case was "mixed," and that laboratory analysis had encountered complications. That update tempered expectations of a rapid breakthrough.
While both the FBI and local authorities remain involved, the perception of differing strategies has fueled public discussion about coordination and leadership.
Online Commentary Expands to Family's Public Role
Alongside questions about investigative direction, online commentary has also focused on the public visibility of the Guthrie family.
Podcaster Zack Peter wrote on social media:
"But the bigger question is WHY isn't the Guthrie family pushing back? They've been virtually absent. No press conferences. No search party."
Others have similarly asked where family members, including Savannah and Annie Guthrie, have been during the ongoing search.
Authorities, however, have formally cleared the Guthrie family of suspicion. Sheriff Nanos publicly stated that neither Savannah Guthrie, Annie Guthrie, nor Annie's husband Tommaso Cioni are considered suspects.
Speculation had circulated after reports noted that Nancy had dinner with Annie the evening before she disappeared and that Cioni was among the last to see her. Those theories were later dismissed by investigators.
Focus Remains on Finding Answers
At this stage, there is no official confirmation of conflict between agencies. The FBI continues to assist. The sheriff's department maintains primary control.
High-profile missing person cases often draw intense scrutiny, especially when prominent families are involved. Yet investigators have emphasized that the case remains active and ongoing.
For many watching, the central concern is not inter-agency dynamics but resolution. Faith leaders have encouraged prayer and restraint, noting that in moments of uncertainty, patience and compassion matter as much as persistence.
Scripture calls believers to pursue truth while guarding against false judgment - a balance that resonates deeply as public speculation grows.
For now, Nancy Guthrie remains missing. Authorities continue to urge anyone with credible information to come forward.
The search continues.
