News

"At the Cross," "Dear God," "I Love the Lord": How the American Idol Top 3 Made Faith the Story of the Finale


Published: May 14, 2026 07:40 AM EDT
Photo Credit: American Idol/YouTube
Photo Credit: American Idol/YouTube

Nobody scheduled it. Nobody announced it. But somewhere in the middle of American Idol's Season 24 finale, the night stopped being about who would win - and started being about something else entirely.

All three finalists chose, on their own, to fill one of television's biggest stages with worship.

Keyla Richardson, a music teacher and gospel singer from Pensacola, Florida, who began singing in churches as a child, stepped into her hometown performance segment and chose Whitney Houston's "I Love the Lord." It was a deliberate choice - and the judges heard it immediately. Carrie Underwood responded: "I love that you took this opportunity to sing to the Lord." Lionel Richie told her she was there to inspire and lift people up.

Jordan McCullough, a worship director at Zeal Church in Nashville who has spent his entire life in church music, performed Smokie Norful's "Dear God" for his hometown tribute. Richie told him: "You are a teacher, you are a preacher, and you're a helluva singer." Luke Bryan looked at him and said he was coming to his church to hear him sing. McCullough then closed his entire Idol journey the same way he opened it - with "Goodness of God," the worship anthem from his very first audition

And Hannah Harper - the stay-at-home mom from Missouri who carried a song about faith and motherhood all the way to the winner's circle - closed the entire season with Chris Tomlin's "At the Cross (Love Ran Red)," crying through every word as confetti fell around her.

Three finalists. Three different styles - country, gospel, and worship. All three pointing the same direction.

The Gospel Music Association highlighted all three, noting that Harper, McCullough, and Richardson each used their platform on the finale stage to point viewers to Jesus - calling the performances some of the most powerful Christian music moments the show has produced.

What made it remarkable wasn't just that it happened. It's that none of them had to. The biggest night of their careers, millions watching, everything on the line - and all three chose the same thing.

Faith first.

 

More from JubileeCast on American Idol Season 24: